Highlights

  • George Lucas had a treatment ready for a potential sequel trilogy, but Disney decided to go a different way with their sequel trilogy.
  • Fans express disappointment with the underused characters and concepts in the Star Wars sequel trilogy.
  • Having one unified vision, like Lucas' plans, could have led to a better outcome in terms of audience satisfaction.

George Lucas' original Star Wars sequel trilogy plans are back in the public eye after one fan posted choice excerpts from a particularly insightful retrospective on the franchise and the potential direction it could’ve taken.

While there were no concrete plans for another Star Wars trilogy at the time when Disney acquired franchise parent company LucasFilm in 2012, original creator and legendary filmmaker George Lucas did have a treatment ready for a potential sequel trilogy of films by the time the acquisition went through, which he promptly offered to Disney. While there were a lot of solid ideas that would have put up some plotlines that had already been explored in the Star Wars books and other media that would be consigned to the Legends continuity, the powers that be at Disney decided to go a different way with their sequel trilogy.

Related
Star Wars: Andor Season 2 Fan Theory Suggests Huge Cameo Possibility

One Star Wars fan thinks Andor season 2 could feature a significant character appearance, but is it something the Disney Plus show would do?

The Disney sequels would earn mixed reviews, with behind-the-scenes turbulence marring this latest Star Wars trilogy and leading the franchise to an all-time low despite having some strengths. With fans currently in the dark about the franchise's future, user DemiPyramid on Reddit has taken to the site’s r/StarWars board to fuel some discussion of those Lucas-led plans that Disney did away with in favor of the now-canon reality. Posting some photos and excepts from 2018’s The Star Wars Archives, Episodes I — III by author Paul Duncan, DemiPyramid also offered a few quick notes on Lucas’ proposed ideas in the post title, stating, “George Lucas talks about his basic outline for Episodes VII, VIII, IX. —— The story features Luke establishing the New Jedi Order, Leia building the New Republic & becoming Supreme Chancellor in the end.”

The post draws attention to a lot of interesting characters and concepts that were underused by the Star Wars sequel trilogy that was made, including the minute amount of time dedicated to Luke and Leia, the potential for a new, wiser, and more vigilant Jedi Order, and the actual political restructuring needed for the New Republic era to come to fruition. Several fans in the comments opined a preference for the concepts Lucas picked. In contrast, others doubt that these plans were concrete in the filmmaker's mind when he offered them to the company. However, there is an overarching sense of disappointment with the parts as mentioned earlier of the sequel trilogy, even from those who genuinely enjoyed it.

Since its conclusion, many critics have concluded that the Star Wars sequels were doomed to fail from the start because of a fundamental mismatch with director J.J. Abrams' signature approach to filmmaking, which was only exasperated further when director Rian Johnson would approach the trilogy’s second entry with an entirely contradictory vision to what was laid out before. A third filmmaker was even brought in to complete the set, and he would have put his unique spin on the third and final film if he hadn’t had a falling out with Kathleen Kennedy that led to Abrams' return to the director’s chair. Whether or not fans enjoyed the trilogy, it’s easy to admit that having one unified vision, a la Lucas' plans, would have resulted in better audience satisfaction.

While it is a bit too late to implement Lucas' version of events into the Star Wars canon, the company certainly has some more ideas, as Daisy Ridley's Rey is rumored to return for multiple Star Wars movies. How these new projects will affect the current attitude towards the sequels and what parts of Lucas' ideas might make it to the new canon through these additions remains to be seen.

The Star Wars franchise is currently available for streaming on Disney Plus.

star-wars-lucas-films-series-movie
Star Wars

Star Wars is a multimedia franchise created by George Lucas and Lucasfilm Ltd with the 1977 motion picture. The science fiction franchise follows the adventures of characters (both humanoid and alien) in outer space, including those who can wield a mystical power known as the Force. Since the release of the original trilogy movies, the franchise has expanded to include multiple films and branched out to other mediums like comics, video games, TV shows, theme park attractions, and more. The IP and Lucasfilm were sold to Disney in 2012.

More
How a Star Wars: Jedi Threequel Can Continue to Expand its Lightsaber Combat

Star Wars Jedi: Survivor added a whole slew of new features to lightsaber combat, but there's still room for a sequel to continue expanding on it.

Source: Reddit/DemiPyramid