Highlights

  • There are some amazing strategy games that offers unforgiving gameplay with high replay value due to random elements and permanent death.
  • Civilization 6, for instance, provides accessible 4X strategy gameplay with diverse leaders and online multiplayer.
  • Age Of Empires 2, on the other hand, offers replayability through multiple campaigns, unique civilizations, and skirmish mode.

Although the popularity of strategy games has waned since its peak in the 90s and early 2000s, particularly in the RTS genre, strategy games have been seeing a resurgence in recent years. This is especially so in the indie game scene, with games such as Against The Storm, RimWorld, and Thronefall all performing well on the Steam storefront.

Related
Retro RTS Games With Great Stories

Some of the older RTS games had incredible stories, and this is especially the case for these classics.

As a result, now is a great time to jump into strategy games, both new and old. These are just a few examples of strategy games with high replay values, all of which fit their own niches in the strategy game genre.

6 XCOM 2

Unforgiving Gameplay Encourages Multiple Playthroughs

XCOM 2

Platform(s)
PS4 , Xbox One , Switch , PC , Android , iOS
Released
February 5, 2016
Developer(s)
Firaxis Games
Genre(s)
Strategy , RPG

Like its predecessors, XCOM 2 delivers on unforgiving turn-based tactics, all while ensuring the game is accessible to newcomers. In XCOM, each battle can play out in a wildly different manner every time, thanks to a dizzying array of variables, including enemy types, random chance, and the environment itself. This ensures that each playthrough of XCOM will never quite pan out the same way twice.

Related
XCOM 2: The Best Classes, Ranked

XCOM 2 is all about tactics and thinking ahead. To do this and still succeed requires the best class available.

The long-running XCOM series is known for its unforgiving gameplay and tactical, strategic combat in which every decision matters. The occasional injections of random chance, permanent death mechanics, and the sheer fact that players can lose the game and be forced to start over, make XCOM a delightfully replayable experience.

5 Civilization 6

Accessible Turn-Based Strategy On A Grand Scale

Sid Meier's Civilization 6

Platform(s)
PS4 , Xbox One , Switch , PC , Android , iOS
Released
October 21, 2016
Developer(s)
Firaxis Games
Genre(s)
Strategy

The Civilization series is known for its accessible 4X strategy gameplay, as well as its massive replay value. This replay value is facilitated through dense gameplay mechanics that encourage multiple strategies, and the unpredictability of online multiplayer ensures that each game plays out differently.

Civilization 6, like its predecessors, features a variety of notable leaders that players can take advantage of. This in and of itself adds a dash of replay value to the game, but it's Civilization's well-crafted gameplay loop that rewards players for repeat plays. The randomly generated elements of the game also help to prevent it from becoming stale, allowing players to play the game multiple times and still be surprised. Although Civilization can be played in single-player, it's arguably better - and more replayable - when played online in a large group.

4 Age Of Empires 2

Multiple Campaigns And A Skirmish Mode With Over Thirty Civilizations

Age of Empires 2: Definitive Edition

Released
November 14, 2019
Developer
Forgotten Empires, Tantalus, Wicked Witch
Genre(s)
Real-Time Strategy

Real-time strategy games like StarCraft 2 are notorious for their complex mechanics and steep learning curves, especially in online multiplayer. For this reason, playing match after match is necessary to learn the game, and these games are built for replaying as a result. Age Of Empires 2, however, is replayable even without its multiplayer features. This is thanks to the variety of ways players can enjoy the game.

Age Of Empires 2 can be played in a variety of ways; the game features a plethora of single-player campaigns along with a skirmish mode that can be played both in single-player and with other players online. Furthermore, the game features an abundance of unique civilizations for players to control, each with their own unique strengths and weaknesses.

3 Total War: Medieval 2

Massive Scale And Deep Systems Ensure Each Campaign Is Different

Total War: Medieval 2

Platform(s)
Android , Microsoft Windows , iOS , macOS
Released
November 10, 2006
Developer(s)
Creative Assembly
Genre(s)
Real-Time Strategy , Turn-Based Strategy , Tactical

For the most part, each of the games in the Total War franchise features a high replay value, thanks to a focus on strategic gameplay and tactical battles that encourage players to take a different approach each time they play the game.

The turn-based, large-scale strategy combined with massive real-time battles make for a satisfying loop that rarely gets stale, and the tide of a battle can change dramatically from just a handful of decisions. These dynamic battles make up much of the fun in Total War, giving players a reason to come back again and again.

Related
The Most Historically Accurate Video Games Ever Made, Ranked

Many developers play fast and loose with factual accuracy in favor of creating an enjoyable playing experience. However, this has started to change.

As with many Total War games, Total War: Medieval 2 features a campaign that tasks players with taking over a certain number of territories. In a campaign, players can take on the role of one of several factions, and the game's large scale and deep systems ensure each campaign plays differently from the last.

2 Hearts Of Iron 4

Deep, Complex, And Inaccessible

Hearts of Iron 4

Platform(s)
PC
Released
June 6, 2016
Genre(s)
Grand Strategy

Hearts Of Iron 4 is a historical simulation game that takes place during WW2 and tasks players with leading a nation of their choice, making strategic and diplomatic choices at every turn. Due to its nature as an inaccessible, massively complex grand strategy title, Hearts Of Iron 4 is an inherently replayable strategy game. In fact, newcomers to the genre are unlikely to even see everything that Hearts Of Iron 4 has to offer until they've played it for a fair few hours.

Even after players have spent hours learning Hearts Of Iron 4, the game can take infinitely longer to master, and the abundance of decisions that players must make in any one playthrough ensures that the game plays out differently every time.

1 StarCraft 2

A Competitive Experience With Asymmetric Factions

StarCraft 2

Platform(s)
PC , macOS
Released
July 27, 2010
Developer(s)
Blizzard
Genre(s)
Real-Time Strategy

Releasing all the way back in 2010, StarCraft 2 is arguably one of the greatest video game sequels. Although its competitive scene isn't what it used to be, StarCraft 2 is still very much an active game with a solid, albeit experienced player base.

StarCraft 2's competitive ladder, along with its three wildly different asymmetric factions, is what gives it such high replay value. Thanks to the hundreds of decisions that players are forced to make throughout a match of StarCraft 2, every game can be played completely differently from the one before. This, along with the game's various single-player campaigns, gives players plenty to do. Furthermore, the game was made free-to-play in 2017.

4:28
MORE
The Best RTS Games To Play If You Love Starcraft

Many fans will be itching for a similar game to Starcraft to play with no new sequel in sight. Here are the best games to scratch that itch.