Highlights

  • Doom 4 was canceled due to its resemblance to Call of Duty and lack of " DOOM -like elements", earning it the nickname " Call of Doom ".
  • The game series Eye of Argonia/Paradise Sugar was canceled due to poor reception of the third-person action-adventure game Redguard .
  • Battlecry , a free-to-play hero shooter set in a steampunk Victorian-style world, was shelved after Bethesda Austin was tasked with working on Fallout 76 .

Bethesda, more than video games (or re-releases of Skyrim) sell dreams; dreams of infinite worlds or star systems, fantasies of power in pristine worlds, or reveries of mechanized mayhem in post-apocalyptic playgrounds. They have taken chances (and have succeeded or failed) with big projects. But since there is only so much time in the world and investor patience, some of Bethesda's biggest ambitions were left grounded so that other projects could take off.

Related
6 Of The Best Games Published By Bethesda, Ranked

Bethesda is well-known for publishing iconic games, but which of its works stand out the most?

Some of these abandoned projects even have documentation of their progress, some were midway through cooking, while others were simply a sparkle in Todd Howard's eye and a few design documents lost in some desk draw. While Bethesda has pulled off some masterworks in its prime, as the chess club master himself would (never) say, sometimes a project just doesn't work.

6 Doom 4

cancelled doom 4
  • The game was in development until sometime in 2013
  • The protagonist was planned to be someone other than the Doom Slayer

Many gamers may be thanking their lucky lords of Hell that this one never came to fruition given the incredible, rip-raw quality of DOOM (2016). While Bethesda did go on to publish it, ID Software ultimately brought the new adventures of the Doom Slayer to life, but the legendary Maryland-based studio was once knee-deep in the demon trenches trying to resurrect the franchise sometime in 2013.

The game was canceled due to its resemblance to the then-red-hot Call of Duty franchise and lack of "DOOM-like elements" (presumably the speed, gore, and bombastic gameplay that the earlier games were known for), earning it the nickname "Call of Doom." Thanks to a short documentary by YouTube's own NoClip, fans can look at what could have been and breathe a (fiery) sigh of relief.

5 The 10th Planet

The Tenth Planet
  • Bethesda described the game as a cross between Star Wars: X-Wing and Starfox
  • The "10th planet" referred to a far, undiscovered world in the Sol system used as a base by invading aliens

Many followers of Bethesda's works will know that Starfield was a game the company had been wanting years, even decades, to make. Perhaps the seeds of Starfield began with a little game called The 10th Planet, which was being developed between Bethesda and another studio called Centropolis. Only a dark and mysterious trailer exists showing off the world and some of the story beats of the game.

Related
The 10 Coolest Spaceships In Video Game History, Ranked

You can't have a good science fiction video game without awesome spacecraft. Today, we're ranking the coolest, most iconic spaceships in gaming.

In reality, however, the game was canned before pre-production had finished because they "couldn't get the game looking as good" as the promotional material, and Centropolis had other commitments to meet. The game would have featured a war-torn solar system, fleets of reptilian alien invaders, and some jaw-dropping spaceship designs. Perhaps the company felt burned on the project even so many decades later, with Starfield's ships giving a realistic, clean, NASA-punk look, winning out over the lurid and alien styling of their lost sci-fi epic.

4 Eye Of Argonia / Paradise Sugar

Elder Scrolls Adventures Redguard
  • Two ambitious Adventures games were planned as sequels to Redguard
  • The spinoff series was canceled due to poor reception to Cyrus' third-person, action-adventure outing

During their Morrowind era, Bethesda was stretching their creative muscles by trying to tell as many stories about the world of the Elder Scrolls as they could. While ambitious (but highly flawed), 1998's Elder Scrolls Adventures: Redguard didn't do as well as Bethesda had hoped. However, some fans may be surprised to hear that the swashbuckling pirate adventure was intended to be the first in a series of three.

The series would have taken players to the mysterious, murky, and inhospitable swamps of Black Marsh in a title called "Eye of Argonia." The third, "Paradise Sugar," would have sent players to the Khajiit land of Elseweyr, a vast expanse of jungle and desert sands, birthplace of the highly addictive fictional substance, moon sugar. Although very little is known about the projects, Elder Scrolls players at least got to see these provinces in The Elder Scrolls Online, without having to deal with the jank of Redguard's engine.

3 Battlecry

Battlecry Faction
  • Battlecry would have been a free-to-play, third-person hero shooter in the vein of TF2 and Valorant
  • The game would have taken place in a steampunk, Industrial Revolution, Victorian-style setting

At a time when games like Overwatch were practically printing money for studios all over the gaming world, it must have only been natural for the money heads at Bethesda to toy with the idea of building a game like that of their own. The result was Battlecry, created by then-named Battlecry Studios (now Bethesda Austin). The game has an industrial-revolution look to it with serious Dishonored vibes.

The team originally set up the studio to bring their vision to life. Unfortunately, after their acquisition, they were tasked with tinkering with Bethesda's Creation engine to make way for Fallout 76's multiplayer. By 2015, the game was de facto shelved. While this type of multiplayer battler was a dime a dozen in the mid-2010s, it is a shame that Battlecry never saw the light of day, as being a Bethesda-led title, the hero shooter would likely have been packed with great lore and world-building. However, after so many years since the last playable demo in 2015, any fresh news about the game is unlikely to surface.

2 Prey 2

Prey 2
  • Would have followed a US solider-turned-bounty hunter on an alien world
  • Finally canceled for Arkane Studios' Prey (2017)

After an abduction, a US soldier finds themselves on a Cyberpunk-alien world called Exodus. The original was filled with weird, alien weaponry, Portal-esque portals (pre-Portal), and death-cheating spirit-roaming segments. Any fan of this would-be series will attest that it had all the makings of a much-beloved franchise. Alas, it was not to be.

Related
8 Great Sequel Games That Failed To Resurrect Their Franchises

These video game sequels were a lot of fun to play but unfortunately failed to breathe new life into their respective franchises.

While Arkane Studios' Prey (2017) turned out to be one of the greatest first-person immersive sims of all time, many Prey fans still feel burned that a sequel to their beloved Prey is forever lost, in part thanks to Bethesda's use of the franchise's name (just to retain the rights), and because the game's Alpha looked so promising in a hands-on presentation at E3 2011. In more bad news, for gamers who did not have the pleasure of experiencing it, the original is still unavailable on most PC digital storefronts.

1 The Elder Scrolls Travels: Oblivion (PSP)

Oblivion Travels
  • Bethesda attempted to squeeze the grandeur of Oblivion into the PSP
  • Travels: Oblivion was set to take place in 10 levels across Tamriel

This game was in development long enough that there is even footage of some early builds of the game floating about online. The Elder Scrolls Travels: Oblivion (presumably the "travels" part comes from the PSP's portability, as with the other Travels entry, the N-Gage's Shadowkey) was the impressive attempt at putting Oblivion's then-groundbreaking visuals into the PSP. Rather than attempting an open world, Bethesda wisely decided to plan for ten levels with a central hub location tying it together.

While that may sound disappointing, the story would take the player all across the continent of Tamriel (but with a focus on High Rock) in a battle against a mysterious figure named "Zhurl" in a story that took place parallel to the Oblivion that fans know, love, and meme on today. The idea was to show off that the Oblivion Crisis brought on by Manmankar Camoran and Dagoth Ur was a continent-wide event that engulfed every part of the empire.

MORE: Funniest Quests In The Elder Scrolls Games